crosslisting logo long

The Art of Negotiation On Poshmark – A Seller’s Guide

art of negotiation on poshmark

As a seller on Poshmark, you just don’t have to list items for sale, you also have to actively participate in a dynamic community of fashionistas, bargain-hunters, and savvy negotiators. And if you want to be a successful seller, mastering the art of negotiation on Poshmark is an absolute must.

Negotiating on Poshmark is a delicate dance. It’s not just about haggling over prices, it’s about building relationships, understanding your buyers, and finding creative solutions that work for everyone involved. No matter if you’re a veteran seller or just starting out, there’s always room to improve your negotiation skills and take your Poshmark selling game to the next level.

In this blog, we’ll explore the ins and outs of negotiation on Poshmark, from setting the right prices to responding to offers, from dealing with lowballers to offering bundle discounts. We’ll also share a few tips with you about how to negotiate with buyers while providing you with actionable negotiation strategies to help you close more sales and grow your reselling business on Poshmark. So get ready to master the art of negotiation on Poshmark!

6 Tips to Master the Art of Negotiation on Poshmark

1- Price your Listings Smartly:

poshmark pricing

As a seller on Poshmark, one of the most critical aspects of negotiation is pricing your items smartly. Setting the right price helps attract buyers and increase the likelihood of receiving offers.

Before listing your items on Poshmark, it’s essential to research the market value of similar products. One way to do this is by browsing through listings of comparable items to see how much they are selling for. You can also check out other e-commerce sites like eBay, Depop, Mercari, and Etsy to get an idea of the current market value.

Once you have an idea of how much your item is worth, you can then price it accordingly. Setting a fair price not only attracts buyers but also ensures that you receive an offer that’s close to your asking price. However, pricing your items too high can discourage potential buyers from making an offer or negotiating.

Poshmark buyers are looking for a good deal, so they will likely try to negotiate the price with you. If you’ve priced your item too high, buyers may be less inclined to negotiate, assuming that you’re not willing to lower your asking price. On the other hand, if your price is reasonable, buyers may be more likely to make an offer or negotiate a lower price.

2- Be Super Active When It Comes to Responding to Negotiation Queries:

be super active when it comes to responding to negotiation queries

Being a Poshmark seller isn’t easy, you have to be very responsible and active when it comes to responding to negotiation offers and queries. When a buyer is interested in your item, he/she is likely to have questions or make an offer to initiate a negotiation. By responding to those queries fast, you demonstrate that you value their interest.

Poshmark is a highly competitive marketplace, and there are many sellers offering similar products. Therefore, quick and timely responses can be the difference between securing a sale or losing out to another seller. A delayed response could lead the buyer to assume that you are not interested or are unreliable, and they may move on to another seller.

Moreover, responding to negotiation queries fast helps sellers build a good reputation on Poshmark. As you respond to inquiries and offers quickly and efficiently, buyers are more likely to rate you highly and leave positive feedback. This can attract more customers to your profile and increase your sales.

It’s important to note that being active on the platform and responding quickly doesn’t mean you have to accept every offer or answer every question. Take the time to carefully consider offers and respond thoughtfully to any queries. However, don’t leave the buyer waiting for a long period. Always, respond to queries from buyers within a reasonable timeframe.

3- Be Friendly and Professional:

be friendly and professional

You can’t crack a negotiation deal with the buyer on Poshmark if you don’t know how to communicate professionally. As a Posh seller, it is important to remain friendly and professional during the negotiation process. This not only helps to maintain a positive relationship with potential buyers but also increases the odds of a successful sale.

When negotiating with potential buyers, it is important to remember that they are also customers. Therefore, it is a must to treat them with respect and professionalism. This means avoiding aggressive or confrontational language that may make the buyer feel uncomfortable or offended.

Instead, use friendly and courteous language to engage with potential buyers. Be responsive to their inquiries, and be willing to listen to their concerns and preferences. This shows that you value their time and are committed to having a deal with them.

Moreover, it is important to remain professional throughout the negotiation process. This means avoiding any behavior that may be perceived as unprofessional, such as using slang, using all caps, or sending inappropriate messages. These actions can damage your reputation as a seller and may deter potential buyers from doing business with you.

4- Strategize Your Counteroffer:

strategize your counteroffer

It’s common for buyers on Poshmark to make offers that are lower than your asking price, therefore, it’s important for you to strategize how you can going to counter that offer made by the buyers.

The best way to handle lowball offers is to counteroffer them strategically. Rather than immediately rejecting an offer, consider countering with a slightly higher price that still represents a good deal for the buyer.

For instance, if you listed an item for $50 and a buyer offers $40, you could counter with $47. This still gives the buyer a discount off the original asking price, but it also shows that you value your item and aren’t willing to go too low.

It’s important to keep in mind that every situation is unique, and there may be times when it’s appropriate to accept a low offer or to counter with a higher price. You should also consider factors such as the condition of the item, how long it’s been listed, and how many similar items are available on Poshmark.

5- Offer Bundle Discounts:

poshmark bundle discount offer

For Poshmark sellers, offering bundle discounts is a very effective negotiation strategy to increase sales and make the buying experience more enticing for potential customers. A bundle discount refers to a discount given to a buyer when they purchase multiple items from your closet at once. This strategy can be a win-win for both parties, as buyers get a better deal and sellers increase their sales volume.

To offer a bundle discount, you can set up a sale in your closet and select the items you want to include in the bundle. Then, you can set a discounted price for the bundle, which will be automatically calculated for the buyer at checkout. Some sellers choose to offer a percentage discount, such as 10% off a bundle of three or more items, while others set a flat rate discount, such as $10 off a bundle of two or more items.

Offering a bundle discount can make negotiating with buyers easier because you can use it as a bargaining chip during the negotiation process. For instance, if a buyer makes an offer that is lower than your asking price, you can counter with a slightly higher price but also offer a bundle discount if they purchase multiple items from your closet. This can incentivize the buyer to add more items to their purchase and ultimately increase your sales.

In addition to making negotiation easier, offering bundle discounts can also lead to repeat customers. If a buyer has a positive experience purchasing a bundle from your closet, they may be more likely to return and make additional purchases in the future.

6- Know When to Walk Away From Negotiation:

know when to walk away from poshmark negotiation

If you want to learn the art of negotiation on Poshmark then it’s important to know when to walk away from a potential buyer. This is especially true when the buyer is being unreasonable or disrespectful in their negotiation attempts. While it may be tempting to try and salvage the sale, it’s important to remember that your time and energy are valuable.

If a buyer is making demands that are outside of the terms you have established in your listing, or is consistently offering lowball prices that don’t reflect the value of your item, it may be time to decline their offer and move on.

Similarly, if a buyer is being rude, aggressive, or disrespectful in their communication with you, it’s okay to end the conversation and move on to the next potential buyer.

It’s important to maintain a professional and respectful tone in all of your interactions with buyers, but that doesn’t mean you have to tolerate disrespectful behavior. Remember that you are in control of the sale, and you have the right to set boundaries and expectations for your buyers.

By knowing when to walk away from a potential buyer who is being unreasonable or disrespectful, you can protect your time and energy, and focus on finding a buyer who is a better fit for your item.

In some cases, it may be possible to salvage the sale by communicating with the buyer and finding a compromise that works for both parties. However, this should only be attempted if the buyer is respectful and willing to engage in a productive conversation. If a buyer is consistently demanding or disrespectful, it’s best to end the conversation and move on.


Negotiation is an important skill to master on Poshmark in order to maximize your profits and make successful transactions. Understanding the value of your items, being confident in your pricing, and effectively communicating with potential buyers are key elements to successful negotiations.

It’s also important to remember that negotiation is a two-way street, and finding a mutually beneficial agreement is the ultimate goal.

Don’t be afraid to walk away from a negotiation if it doesn’t feel right, and always maintain professionalism and courtesy throughout the process. With practice and patience, negotiation can become a valuable tool in your Poshmark selling arsenal.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: Why is negotiation important on Poshmark?

A: Negotiation can help buyers and sellers on Poshmark reach a fair price for an item and can increase the likelihood of a successful sale. Negotiation is also a key part of building relationships with other users on the platform.

Q: What are some tips for successful negotiation on Poshmark?

A: A few tips for successful negotiation on Poshmark include doing research on comparable items, being polite and respectful in your communication with buyers, and being willing to compromise to reach a mutually agreeable price.

Q: What should I do if I can’t reach a deal through negotiation?

A: If you can’t reach a deal through negotiation, you can either walk away from the transaction or consider other options, such as bundling items or offering discounts for multiple purchases.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *